Crafted with Care: Our Homemade Artisanal Ice Creams

At Lucy’s, we believe dessert should be nothing short of extraordinary. That’s why our artisanal ice creams are lovingly made from scratch using only the finest ingredients — real fresh cream, milk, whole eggs, and egg yolks — with no artificial flavors or shortcuts. Each batch begins with a rich custard, gently cooked at low temperatures while stirred constantly to achieve the perfect silky texture.

What inspired us to create our own ice creams? The truth is, most commercial ice creams today are filled with artificial flavors, cheap shortenings, preservatives, and chemical additives — ingredients that don’t belong in food, let alone something as joyful as ice cream. We wanted to bring it back to what it should be: honest, natural, and delicious.

We let nature speak for itself with four thoughtfully crafted flavors:

• Pure Vanilla — Made with natural vanilla extract for a clean, aromatic finish

• 100% Real Chocolate — Deep and decadent, using only true chocolate for full-bodied flavor

• Wild Berries — A vibrant blend of strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries, naturally sweet and tangy

• Key Lime Pie — Bright and creamy with freshly squeezed limes, sweetened condensed milk, and crumbled Biscoff cookies

These ice creams are the perfect match for our famous homemade pies — or a delicious treat on their own, topped with your choice of chocolate, strawberry, or caramel syrup.

Whether paired or solo, every scoop is a taste of tradition — made fresh with care, and free from the toxic additives we all want to avoid.

Come savor the difference at Lucy’s.

Our Menu!